For years, the United States government and
public have speculated about China’s likely rise as a global power in the near
future. The thought of the United States losing its status as the lone
superpower often brings contempt towards the rising state. As G. John Ikenberry
argues in his article The Rise of China
and the Future of the West. Can the Liberal System Survive?, the United
States can ultimately decide the outcome of China’s inevitable rise in one of
two ways: push the state away, offering no aid and expecting their demise or integrate them into the Western Order.
In order for the United States to remain powerful, they should aid this power.
Helping China rise and incorporating the state into the western world will
either give the United States the chance to take a back seat or continue to be
most powerful if integration fails.
Giving
aid and support to China as a rising superpower and integrating them into the
Western Order will presumably end in the United States becoming the second most
powerful state in the order. As Ikenberry states, “the rise of China does not
have to trigger a wrenching hegemonic transition” because China faces “a
Western-centered system that is open, integrated, and rule-based, with wide and
deep political foundations,” (Ikenberry). China’s rise will not result in
global tragedy as the rise of states in the past has because the politics of
today’s international world have changed. If the United States allows China to
surpass them within the Western Order, they will simply be second in line of an
order that will continue to deeply depend on them due to location. Though it is
possible for China to become more powerful than the United States within the
Western Order, the United States will always have some power over the western
world due to their location; they are in the west while China is in the east.
This will allow the United States to take a step back from international
disorder. In recent history, the United States has usually been expected to
deal with problems that arise within less stable states simply because they are
seen as the leader. An example of such a situation is the recent struggle with
Syria. Most states can agree that there are problems in Syria and that
intervention or other aid is needed to bring the country to order. However, the
United States remains seemingly unwilling to enter such a situation and other states
continue to look to them to do something. All in all, letting China take over
as a superpower could allow the United States to focus on problems at home.
Attempting
to integrate China into the Western Order is the best option for the United
States when dealing with this rising power. The attempt could fail, resulting
in the United States remaining the sole superpower. However, the attempt could
also be a success; China could become the most powerful state in the Western
Order. If this were to happen, the United States would be able to take a back
seat when dealing with international problems. Although the façade of the
United States as a force fighting for good would remain, they could allow China
to rise as a superpower and become such a force as well. Additionally, the
United States would not lose complete superpower status because of their
location. The majority of states in the Western Order are, in fact, located in
the west. Therefore, the United States could still remain a regional power due
to location since China is located in the east. Having China become a
superpower will not be detrimental to the United States and could even help the
state focus on the interests of its government and citizens.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWhile I see your point that brining China into the western order could be beneficial, as the current leader of the western world and hegemon, is it really in our best interest to provide a socialist country such as China with additional power, resources and allies?
ReplyDeleteCouldn't you argue that the alternative is a greater evil? If we attempt to subdue the power of China, I think that we could disturb our alliance with China and risk creating an enemy with a world superpower.
DeleteI agree with Sarah that the result of pushing China away probably would not end well. Also, is China being a socialist country a problem in modern times?
Delete